Lesson 14: The Earthly Sanctuary and the Heavenly Pattern
April 17, 2024Hebrews 9:1-10
Now even the first covenant had regulations for worship and an earthly sanctuary. For a tent was constructed, the first one, in which were the lampstand, the table, and the bread of the Presence; this is called the Holy Place. Behind the second curtain was a tent called the Holy of Holies. In it stood the golden altar of incense and the ark of the covenant overlaid on all sides with gold, in which there were a golden urn holding the manna, and Aaron’s rod that budded, and the tablets of the covenant; above it were the cherubim of glory overshadowing the mercy seat. Of these things we cannot speak now in detail.
Such preparations having been made, the priests go continually into the first tent to carry out their ritual duties; but only the high priest goes into the second, and he but once a year, and not without taking the blood that he offers for himself and for the sins committed unintentionally by the people. By this the Holy Spirit indicates that the way into the sanctuary has not yet been disclosed as long as the first tent is still standing. This is a symbol of the present time, during which gifts and sacrifices are offered that cannot perfect the conscience of the worshiper, but deal only with food and drink and various baptisms, regulations for the body imposed until the time comes to set things right.
The “first covenant” had an earthly sanctuary that imitated the heavenly sanctuary. The architecture and furniture of the earthly sanctuary reflect the meaning and significance of the heavenly sanctuary. Its space, practices, and symbols—its liturgy—bear witness to the heavenly reality. It was built according to what Moses saw in his vision of God’s holy space. Consequently, it is important to understand what “the Holy Spirit indicates” by arranging the earthly sanctuary in this way. This is important because it prepares us to understand the climactic event in the heavenly sanctuary when the Messiah offered himself before the face of God and continues at the right hand of God to make intercession for us.
The assembly of renewed Israel (through the new covenant) is not patterned after the earthly sanctuary. On the contrary, the assembly of renewed Israel upon the earth participates in the reality of the heavenly sanctuary. The worship (liturgy or service, latreias) of the assembled believers in Jesus is patterned after the heavenly sanctuary, and the gathered people (the assembly of Jesus the Messiah) worship with the angels, the saints who have gone before, and the whole assembly of God spread throughout the earth. If the worship of the “church” (the ekklesia of Hebrews 2:12 and Hebrews 12:23) has a pattern for its liturgy (latreias), it is the liturgy of heaven itself around the throne of God.
Jesus himself is the liturgist (leitourgos) in the heavenly sanctuary (Hebrews 8:2). He leads the assembled people of God in the heavenly sanctuary and performs the high priestly duties of offering and intercession. He serves in a sanctuary with seven lights (torches) that burn before the throne of God, which represents the Holy Spirit (Revelation 4:5). The saints, who are also priests, offer prayers upon the altar of incense (Revelation 5:7; 8:3). Both Israel (the twelve tribes) and the church (the twelve apostles) offer praise before the throne of God (Revelation 4:4, 10) as they cast down their crowns (Revelation 4:10; 5:8) and fall down before God (Revelation 5:14) as the redeemed people and the whole creation sing hymns of praise (Revelation 5:8-14; 14:1; 15:3) and the Sanctus (holy, holy, holy) in Revelation 4:8. They pray and praise, even with instruments like Israel in their liturgy (Revelation 5:8; 14:2; 15:2; cf. Psalms 22:1; 32:3; 71:22; 144:9; 150:3). We might even see a liturgy of the Word in the light of the book in the right hand of God and through the proclamations of God throughout the heavenly realm (Revelation 5:1-5). Indeed, when we eat at the table of the Lord in the kingdom of God (gathering around the Lord’s Supper), we participate in the heavenly liturgy that includes table fellowship at the Messianic banquet where Jesus eats with us in the kingdom (cf. Matthew 26:29; Luke 22:30). This is also pictured, ultimately, as the marriage supper of the Lamb (Revelation 19:6). There is a table in the church because there is a Messianic banquet celebrated in the heavenly sanctuary where the redeemed people of God hunger or thirst no more (Revelation 7:16).
The gathering of Christ-followers (the new covenant assembly of renewed Israel) is patterned after the heavenly sanctuary, just as the earthly sanctuary of Israel was also patterned after it. The synagogue was not the pattern for assemblies among early believers in Jesus the Messiah. Rather, it was the temple, the heavenly temple which was imitated (or copied) by the earthly sanctuary found in Israel’s Tabernacle and Temple. Today, when Jesus-followers gather, we participate in the heavenly temple, the real and original sanctuary.
The earthly sanctuary, or tent, was constructed by Moses (a tent made with human hands, Hebrews 9:24). Its regulations for liturgy (service, latreias) and its furniture belong to this age, this earthy creation (cosmikon). At the same time, its liturgy and furniture are not meaningless or insignificant. They carry the weight of God’s glory upon the earth and testify to the significance of the heavenly sanctuary. Consequently, it is important to pay close attention to its liturgy, space, and furniture in order to hear the point the preacher is making. He did not need to detail its function for his audience because they were well-aware of the tabernacle’s liturgy and furniture (“of these things we cannot speak now in detail”), but perhaps we need to fill in the blanks of our own understanding so that we don’t miss the preacher’s point.
Holy Place (the “first tent”), which one enters with the offerings of the altar of sacrifice.
- The lampstand or menorah with seven lamps (Exodus 25:31-40; 37:17-24), which burns endlessly in God’s presence and gives light to the Holy Place. It is the light of God blessing Israel as well as giving light to a dark space that has no windows.
- The table with the bread of presence (Exodus 25:23-30), which the priests ate and replaced weekly. The twelve loaves represented the twelve tribes of Israel. It symbolized a thanksgiving meal between God and the people as there was a vessel for drink offering on the table as well (Numbers 4:7).
Holy of Holies (after the “second curtain”), which one enters with the censer from the altar of incense (Leviticus 16:12-13).
- Golden altar of incense (Exodus 30:10; Leviticus 16:16-16), with the censer from this altar the high priest enters the Holy of Holies; thus, functionally, the Holy of Holies “has” the incense altar in its space. Or, the altar was inside the Holy of Holies in the temple of Solomon (1 Kings 6:20, 22), and there was a tradition among some second Temple Jewish believers that suggested this as well (2 Apocalypse of Baruch 6:7; cf. Revelation 8:3; 9:13). Some think the preacher is drawing on a reading in the Samaritan Pentateuch, which is a third textual tradition (in addition to the traditional Hebrew text and the Septuagint). Or, some suggest the altar of incense was moved into the Holy of Holies for the Day of Atonement.
- Golden Ark of the Covenant, containing (or placed before the ark).
- Golden urn or jar of manna (Exodus 16:32-34)
- Aaron’s rod that budded (Numbers 17:10-11)
- Tablets of the covenant (Exodus 25:16; Deuteronomy 10:1-5)
- The cherubim of glory overshadowing the mercy seat (Exodus 25:10-22; 37:1-9), which is the earthly throne of God (Psalms 80:2; 99:1), and the mercy seat is the place where the blood is sprinkled on the Day of Atonement (Leviticus 16:1-19).
Several points are particularly significant as they prepare us for the preacher’s argument in the rest of Hebrews 9.
First, the separation of and movement between the Holy Place and the Holy of Holies is of paramount importance. The liturgy teaches us about the separation of God and the people for the sake of holiness. It is a separation of degrees: people in the courtyard of the tabernacle, priests in the Holy Place, and only the high priest in the Holy of Holies. The movement from courtyard to Holy Place is happens only through the altar of sacrifice, where the blood of an animal is poured out. The movement from the Holy Place to the Most Holy Place occurs through the altar of incense, where the high priest takes the blood of Yom Kippur (the Day of Atonement) into the Holy of Holies. The distance between God and the people is represented by these spatial movements. Moreover, priests do not enter with nothing; they bring an offering. Jesus, of course, will enter the heavenly Holy of Holies with his own offering, which is the point of the rest of the preacher’s argument in Hebrews 9-10.
Second, the furniture has often been interpreted typologically, that is, what it might signify about practices in the church (e.g, the table of bread is analogous to or a type of the Lord’s Supper). Whether those typological readings are correct or not, it is not the point of the preacher (though I think they have some merit). He is not concerned about how each piece of furniture relates to ecclesial practices in new covenant assemblies. Rather, he is focused on the movement and its climax. As the high priest moves through the Holy Place with its furniture, he ultimately arrives in the Holy of Holies with its furniture. The goal is the ark of the covenant with all its glory (gold) and its “mercy seat.” His concern is not typological but spatial movement toward the goal. The analogy is not between the tabernacle and the church but between the liturgical movement of the earthly high priest and the liturgical movement of the Messiah in the heavenly sanctuary. Perhaps he mentions the furniture only to highlight the sanctuary and meaning of the space.
The previous point is clarified by Hebrews 9:6-7 from which the preacher draws the teaching of the Holy Spirit in Hebrews 9:8. While priests go continually into the Holy Place (“first tent”) to perform their liturgical rituals, “only the high priest goes into the second.” He does so “once a year” to offer blood for his own sins and the sins of the people. For the preacher, the movement is the point rather than the typological meaning of the furniture. Indeed, it is the teaching of the Holy Spirit, which God taught through the Levitical system serving in an earthly sanctuary. The tabernacle is God’s witness to God’s desire and goal for the people of God.
The “first tent” (the Holy Place in Israel’s tabernacle) imitates a heavenly sanctuary (it a parable or “symbol”); it projects beyond itself to something both original (from the beginning) and climactic (the work of Jesus as high priest). It is the heavenly space that perfects the people of God, not the earthly sanctuary. Priests regularly serve in the “first tent” on a daily basis, but this daily liturgy (service) could not perfect anyone’s conscience (it could not perfect humans for eternal glory and dwelling with God). Further along in Hebrews 9, the preacher will focus on the “second tent” (the Holiest of Holies in Israel’s tabernacle) in his exposition of the meaning of Yom Kippur (the Day of Atonement). The entrance of the high priest into the most inner sanctum of the earthly sanctuary is an annual exception to the daily work of priests in the “first tent.” The Levitical system could not give Israel access, as a people, to the Holy of Holies.
The barrier between the first and second tents, which is also a barrier between the people and God, was only crossed on one day per year. It symbolized the distance and the ineffectual nature of the Levitical service, particularly its sacrifices, for the perfection of God’s people. The regular service of the priests was a reminder of sin and a moment of forgiveness, but it did not effectively remove sin in an eschatological or final way. This is what the “new covenant” does. In this sense the Levitical system was a parable (parabole) or “symbol” (or illustration) of what is to come though the present reality separates Israel from the most Holy Place, the Holy of Holies. The Levitical system was effective for its purposes, and part of its purpose was to imitate, anticipate, and typologically participate in the work of the Messiah in the heavenly sanctuary.
It is important to remember the Levitical system is good, valuable, and effective for its purposes. Its regulations of food and drink, its various baptisms (immersion rituals and washings), and rules regarding the body (flesh) were profitable for teaching and training. They were neither bad nor inherently legalistic. On contrary, they served to consecrate the people of God to God and set them apart as the people of God. And, they indicated something more to come because they imitated the heavenly sanctuary.
Because they were provisional and anticipatory, something was lacking. Due to the sin of Israel, these sacrifices could not perfect the conscience of the worshipper and ensure their obedience to the law. Something more was needed and necessary; something needed correcting because Israel had broken their covenant with God. Thus, a change was needed (Hebrews 7:11, 18) that could ground the salvation of Israel in something heavenly and eternal rather than in something earthly and temporal. The resurrected Messiah became the heavenly high priest who offered a once for all sacrifice while the Levitical high priest annually went into the earthly sanctuary and ultimately died. The correction is the story of the heavenly high priest, Jesus the Messiah, who accomplish eternal redemption in the heavenly sanctuary as part of a heavenly Yom Kippur. That is the story of the rest of Hebrews 9.